Reminder - You can follow along with all of the bout results HERE.
Here's how WRiTE CLUB cage bouts work. Instead of two writers competing against one another, now it's THREE AT ONCE. But there's a twist. All of the winners have been given the opportunity to absorb the feedback offered during their preliminary round and submit an edited version of their original submission. As a writer, utilizing feedback can be a tricky proposition - because frankly - not all feedback is equal. This is our chance to see how the contestants used that feedback (if at all).
Remember, one of the real values of this contest is FEEDBACK. So, please be respectful with your remarks!
1) One vote per visitor per bout.
2) Anyone can vote (even the contestants themselves), but although our contestants are anonymous, voters cannot be. Anonymous votes will not count, so if you do not have a Google account and are voting as a guest, be sure to include your name and email address.
3) Using any method (email, social media, text, etc) to solicit votes for a specific contestant will cause that contestant's immediate disqualification. It’s perfectly okay, in fact, it is encouraged to spread the word about the contest to get more people to vote, just not for a specific writer!
4) Although more of a suggestion than a rule - cast your vote before you read other comments. Do not let yourself be swayed by the opinions of others.
Chapter One
Come
along. If you follow me, we might catch him before he shuts the shop. Stay close to me. These streets are dark and narrow, and
slither through the city like a snake. A
child could easily get lost here. Hurry
now. Down this alleyway – past the
Captain’s Cavern pub and - yes, we’re just in time. Look, he’s closing the shutters. Quietly now.
Don’t let him see us. Slip into
this doorway and peep out carefully.
Ah, you’ve seen him, I can tell. Quite a sight, isn’t he? His name’s Fraser. Fraser Crannog - of the Clan Crannog as he always reminds people. You won’t forget that, will you?
F R A S E R C R A N N O G.
He doesn’t like it if you get his name wrong, and it’s always ‘Mr Crannog’ at first. I know, he’s a wild looking man. If we were a little closer, you’d be able to see his thick, grey caterpillar eyebrows, his radish-red nose, his hair all wild and spiky. But, most of all, you’d see his eyes: sharp, shiny and icy blue. The sort of eyes that seek out your secrets. Your - very - deepest - secrets. Can you see the shop window? Look at those old lamps, antique toys, ancient books, pieces of furniture – all so thick with dust you could write your name in them. Finn does sometimes. Who’s Finn? Oh, you’ll find out soon enough.
Crannog’s Curios – ah, you spotted the sign and yes, you’re right, it is an antique shop – officially. But Fraser sells more than that. Much, much more. But we must go. He’s locked the door – he’s on his way home. Stay quiet. Quiet. He’s passing, so close we could reach out and touch him – can you smell the stale tobacco? That’s from his pipe. He smokes it all the time. He’s walking down the alley now to the main street, his footsteps echoing. He’ll disappear in a moment, into the swirling mist that chokes Edinburgh tonight. Now, let me take you to meet Finn.
***
Here
we are, on the other side of the city.
Look at those gloomy old flats.
Finn Silvers is up there in his tiny bedroom. It smells musty and damp.
Can you see him, looking out from the top floor window, a blanket round his
shoulders? He’s wishing – wishing that he could fly like the birds that are
roosting in the tops of the trees. If he
could, he’d fly back to London, back to the time when his Mum was alive. His old life, where his Dad hadn’t married
Sylvia. It will be tea-time soon. His Mum used to bake and cook lovely meals
with roast potatoes and gravy; Sylvia gives him Spam and cabbage. Finn’s always hungry now. Come, I’ll take you
up. Hold tight.
“Finn! Come here this instant.” Ah, there’s Sylvia - that lemon-faced, bony woman in the frilly apron. Don’t be scared, she can’t see you.
He
didn't have a destination in mind, but when Jael found himself on the catwalk
of one of the three watchtower spires, he finally slowed himself to stand and
look out across the great river that wound down from the Dark Mountains to the
north. The sun was low across the foothills to the west, casting a warm glow
across the cool stone railing.
Jael
gripped the edge and leaned forward. The wind was wild at this height and he
closed his eyes to listen to it as it whipped and whistled around his head.
Autumn was fast approaching and there was a tang of wood smoke and leaves in
the air. He breathed in deeply and reached for his power. It responded like an
eager child, ready to come out and play.
He
stood back from the rail and lifted his hands in front of him. Regealth had
been trying to teach him how to meter the amount of magic he called forth. "Little sips and tastes," the old
mage had explained. Now, Jael raised his hands and called two wisps of blue
electricity. The magic wound through his fingers, the tendrils of energy
pulsing and crackling as they snaked over the backs of his hands.
He
watched it, his eyes narrowing as he tried to gather it in his palms. The magic
fought him and he grimaced, applying more focus. Some of the strands started to
pool together, but others broke off and continued their strange game of chase
around his fingers.
"Sky
magic is always so temperamental," a lilting voice said from behind him.
Jael
dropped his hands and the blue energy dissipated into the air like tiny
lightning bolts. He turned to see a very young woman peek around the curve of
the spire. She grinned.
"Ah,"
he breathed out, "you found me."
"Aye,
my lord," she said, coming closer.
Jael
held his hands back up in front of him.
"I
don't know why it won't do what I wish," he murmured.
The
young woman smiled again. She held one hand up, a crackling sphere of green
energy sitting neatly in her palm.
"Sky
magic is hardest because it is all around us," she began. The sphere
flattened out and began to form a swirling disc.
"It
is like a horse."
She
drew her fingers together and pulled down, calling the disc to form a cyclone.
The wind began to whip around them faster, as if reacting to her magic.
"You
must stay in control so it will do as you ask."
Jael
watched in wonder as she used her other hand to twirl above the spinning
cyclone. Fine tendrils of energy spun out like glass, shimmering in the late
afternoon sun. Then, with one swift move, she pulled her hands apart and the
magic scattered like a fine mist that settled over them both and flickered
away.
"Show
off," Jael smirked.
"Regealth won't
let me play like this when we study," Isabela chuckled.
Driving Me Crazy
“Get off in
Sandnes,” she says.
The website for
the Statens Vegvesen, the Norwegian DPS, calls her a “test sensor.” I
call her—this khaki-uniformed woman who holds my vehicular fate in her
hands—the Ice Queen. Queenie, for short.
The ten minutes
since I pulled out of the Stavanger motor vehicle bureau have been chilly, and
nothing’s wrong with the sedan’s heat. Yep, it’s Queenie, who has a pruny face,
glacial eyes, and the social skills of a Yeti.
I have fifty more
minutes to melt Queenie with my red-hot driving skills and snag that Norwegian
driver’s license. Since my family and I arrived from Houston five months ago,
I’ve avoided the road test, terrified I’ll muff it. Crazy to think, but a few
slips behind the wheel could cost me $4,000 and 20 hours at driving school. I’m
46, not 16, and have much better plans for my money and time.
So, here I am
piloting Queenie smoothly, steadily, and moderately southeast on the motorway
when she tells me to exit. Sandnes has four exits, so Queenie needs to cough up
more info. “This Sandnes exit?” I ask, gesturing toward a blue highway
sign.
Then I reconsider.
Waving one hand around during a driving test—could look reckless. I casually
slide it back to the two o’clock position.
“Do you mean the sentrum
exit?” I ask.
“Ja.”
Not that
rabbit warren! Crap.
Downtown Sandnes
is the cutest for shopping, strolling on the brick-paved pedestrian mall lined
with boutiques. For driving, though, it's a tangled mass of crisscrossing
streets and snack-sized roundabouts lined with cyclists, pedestrians, runners,
and baby carriages, all waiting to leap into the crosswalks and bring oncoming
cars to a halt. I’ve learned two things: stop for crosswalks, and crosswalks
are everywhere.
All the ex-pats
have PTSD from this Sandnes driving hell. “I was white-knuckling the steering
wheel and going about 10 miles an hour,” said Debbie, the triathlete from
Denver.
Jana told me, “I
was trying to turn left, but the green arrow wouldn't come. Sweat was just
streaming down my back, you know? And the test guy kept trying to talk to me.”
She’s from Houston, like me. She failed the test, like I’m about to.
“Turn at the next
right,” says Queenie.
“By the apotek?”
I ask.
She huffs,
brushing something (probably) fake off her jacket sleeve. “Is that the next
right?”
Maybe? As I’ve
learned recently, the “next right” could be the drugstore. Also, it could be a
dead-end alley the width of a Gremlin. Reversing in such a situation really
wakes you up in the morning.
Nonetheless, I
turn right because Queenie says to.
Around the corner, it’s suddenly silent, and we are not
moving. Through my front windshield, I see a red-faced old man shaking his fist
at me. He’s in the crosswalk, and so is my car.
Queenie’s cut the engine, and my Norwegian driving dreams are
dead.
Good morning, writers!
ReplyDeleteTrewalney: As I read your piece this morning, I realized that it makes me feel cozy. Like I'm a child, sick in bed, and a beloved adult is telling me a story to distract me from my fever and aching body. I love this piece and have not solid critiques.
Battlestar Bear: I'm still distracted by all the dialogue tags. "breathed, began, murmured." I know this is a personal preference, but I definitely prefer a plain old "said" if I must use a tag because I like context, the dialogue itself, and actions to clue me into how words are spoken.
Driving Me Crazy: Your revisions definitely gave me a clearer sense of who the driver is, but I almost feel that it wasn't quite enough and it came a bit too late. I still envisioned a teen behind the wheel, and my best guess until they mentioned the names of the other ex-pats, was that it was likely a teen boy. Mainly because I can't imagine a woman or girl thinking of an adult woman as "Queenie" or Ice Queen. BUT I love that I know know WHY the driver must pass their test, even I still can't really picture them fully.
Trelwaney gets my vote today.
My vote today goes to MIM.
ReplyDeleteTrelawney - I don't have any further critiques from last round.
Battlestar Bear - I didn't really notice the dialogue tags in the first round, but now that someone has brought attention to them, I agree, they're a bit distracting. I still think Isabela's name needs to be introduced sooner.
MIM - no further critiques for you, I think your addition of details about the narrator really helped this piece, and I love the change to the ending, it really strengthened the whole piece.
My vote goes to Trelawney.
ReplyDeletevoting for Trelawney--I love the voice of this, a lot.
ReplyDeleteMIM, the revisions you made really clarified this scene for me, especially the stakes and the ending.
ReplyDeleteBattlestar Bear, as before, the world you created captures the imagination.
Trelawney, the voice, again, is fantastic. For that reason, Trelawney gets my vote today.
Trelawney has my vote.
ReplyDeleteTrelawney: This remains a magical, voicey piece. Well done.
Battlestar Bear: If revisions were made, they didn't alter my overall impression. The writing is solid with some nice turns of phrase, but pitted against Trelawney, I wanted something more to pique my interest.
MIM: Your writing is clean and the revisions cleared up some of the questions I had in the prior round, but the story simply doesn't interest me. Sorry!
Voting for MIM!
ReplyDeleteMy vote goes to MIM.
ReplyDeleteTrelawney
ReplyDeleteBeautiful writing, Trelawney. You get my vote.
ReplyDeleteThe other two pieces were very good, but Trelawney's had more depth to the story and wonderful atmosphere.
How do I get an ID on this site?! I have been searching for instructions to vote, but it isn't anywhere!
ReplyDeleteTrelawney's piece is evocative and intriguing and well paced. Clearly the best.
Aaaah! I found it. :-)
DeleteMIM gets my vote. The revisions made things a lot clearer, and I love the humor of this! (So envy anyone who can write good humor.)
ReplyDeleteMy vote is for Trelawny, I would have liked to understand more how these people were connected, but I'm sure that you have a bigger picture that will be revealed later. I liked the unusual voice you chose for the pice, like a story teller.
ReplyDeleteCongratulations to all three writers!
ReplyDeleteI didn’t catch Trelawny’s story earlier. What an interesting voice - how things are described to avoid info dumps while providing info on the world. The jump between locations was a bit odd, felt like part of something bigger. I was a little thrown thinking it was an older era, and the reference to spam brought it to the more modern day.
Battlestar Bear and MIM both brought great revisions to your stories. Having Isabel say My Lord gives an interesting twist to their relationship. The plot of the story for MIM was more smooth this time around.
My vote is for Trelawny.
(I apologize if this suddenly appears in triplicate - Blogger seems to be possessed tonight)
Vote goes to Trelawney. Loved it the first time, still love it. Great revisions to MIM's piece. And a kudos to the admin team for changing up the bout order. Makes for a better competition.
ReplyDeleteMy vote this round is for Trelawny. Congrats all on making it to this round, - MIM your revisions made your piece much cleared.
ReplyDeleteThree great stories. I thought choosing would be easy this time, but turns out, not so much....
ReplyDeleteTrelawney
Beautifully written. You take us on an enjoyable journey. Between Finn’s sad life and Master Crannog’s menacing manner, we’re all set up for the complications that will no doubt come. It feels Dickens-esque, so Spam seems like an anachronism. If it’s not modern day, something like boiled cabbage might work better.
Battlestar Bear
Few revisions that I could see. While it’s skillfully written, I have the same problems with it as before: no stakes and very little tension. Because of that, I found it kind of boring, despite the polished writing. I really needed a hint or two of what the main conflict will be.
MIM
Yours has improved the most. You set up the stakes that were missing in the first version and the ending is more satisfying. I really enjoyed reading this. Great work!
I really enjoyed MIM’s story, but because of the engaging, atmospheric voice, my vote goes to Trelawney.
Three strong pieces here!
ReplyDeleteTrelawney - I still love the whimsy and worldbuilding in this piece. My biggest challenge is that Fraser Crannog's intentions are so ambiguous. Did we just meet the villain or Finn's hero? I don't mind some mystery, but I want to know how I'm expected to feel about the character, even if you end up subverting that later. Obviously, that's just a personal opinion.
Battlestar Bear - Beautiful writing, consistent with the fantasy genre. I do feel like this could have benefited from edits, particularly a sooner intro for Isabela, but I'm giving everyone some grace on that while the world is on fire.
MIM - GREAT edits here. I don't read widely in contemporary humor, but this was clever and very well executed. You get my vote this round!
Trelawney gets my vote. I love the world you created, especially because it seems multilayered. I'm still worried, though, about the spam being anachronistic.
ReplyDeleteBattlestar Bear--very nice writing.
MIM, good edits.
Thanks so all!
Trelawney feels like a picture book that is missing the pictures. But it's an okay read.
ReplyDeleteBattlestar Bear has me wishing I knew the ages of the characters, but it seems like a decent opening to something that could be good. So you get my vote.
MIM- is there an award for most improved in playoffs? I'd give you that. I'm not deeply invested in the MC getting the license, but knowing it'd cost money for failing does help the story. This is a much better 500 words than before.
Trelawney isn't my cup of tea.
ReplyDeleteBattlestar Bear feels like something I'd normally read.
MIM has my vote.